from 20th march 2005
blue volIV, #7
Book Review Archive: Round-Up
#1, January 2005
 
Previous Arts Reviews
Books Available From:
and www.leftbooks.com
If you have hit this page 
and have no navigation:
Click Here

Sea
by John O'Leary, Zim



John O'Leary - toggle-haired, thin-boned, gypsy-looking - lives at the edge of the world where the land meets the sea.

The wave's radiant hand
how it wants,
how it reaches, how
it withdraws

Sea is a collection of sonnets, 77 in all, completing the 77 in O'Leary's earlier companion volume, Salt - on love, dump and weep, the triad that now defines the modern relationship. The set of sonnets that make up Sea bring the reader closer to the poet's world, Allihies on the Beara Peninsula in the south-west of Ireland. If Salt is about love and longing, Sea is about belonging and identity.

It's so different seeing
the land from the sea -
it seems\so easy,

and so temporary,
the way I can feel
your voice in my hands.
I was building with stones today -

desire is like that,
made of amazingly heavy
not-at-all heavenly
bodies, a landfall,

at first immaterial,
later, grasping and gravid and holding me

Review: RA






Collapse:
How Societies Choose to Fail or Survive

by Jared Diamond, Penguin/Allen Lane



There are those who will see this book as the story of the 'Vanished Edens', will read Jared Diamond's analysis and somehow fail to see what he is really saying. If this book is merely an environmental history of human society it will be as worthless as the books that preceded it, notably Clive Ponting's A Green History of the World. Great reading but not a lot of use to the ecological and social problems that face modern societies.

Diamond takes a different approach to Ponting. His is a cultured, scientific approach, the same style that won him a Pulitzer Prize for non-fiction [for Guns, Germs & Steel]. For most of the book Diamond lets the reader work it out by reading between the lines. Near the end he spells it out:

"For the most part we 'just' need the political will to apply solutions already available. Of course that's a big 'just'. But many societies did find the necessary political will in the past."

This is a book about the dangers our modern societies face, the same dangers ancient and older civilisations faced and either failed or survived. Diamond is an optimist but he is also a realist who knows that the dangers facing civilisation today are global, not local. There is no more new frontier.

Review: RA






In Search of Michael Dwyer
by Chris Lawlor, Dunlavin



The myths that surround the west Wicklow United Irishman Michael Dwyer are pervasive in Irish society at home and among the Diaspora. So a book that tells the true story comes as a welcome change to the revisionist histories.

Written by Wicklow historian Chris Lawlor, In Search of Michael Dwyer is carefully structured to highlight the crucial elements in the life of the man the British crown forces could not bring to heel for five years.

Celebrated as the hero of the 1798 rebellion, Dwyer held out in the Wicklow mountains for five years, often escaping his enemies because of his knowledge of the people and their landscape. The Wicklow mountains are today a harsh environment, yet Dwyer felt as much at home within their embrace as he did in the new civilisation that was being imposed on the rural people - who were always people of the land and happy to work the land in ways that today we would describe as sustainable. Dwyer would not have survived in the mountains without an intimate knowledge of the flora and fauna.

Which is why he was never caught.

Review: RA






Limits to Growth
(The 30-year update)

by Meadows, Randers and Meadows, Earthscan



Has human society really wasted 30 years since this book was first published in 1972? Three decades ago Dana Meadows warned that humans were about to overshoot their carrying capacity.

Overshoot is the key word in this book and this time the authors - Dennis Meadows and Jorgen Randers completing Dana Meadows' work (she passed away in 2001) - present ten scenarios for the 21st century. Some are optimistic, some are pessimistic. But the reality is still the same - overshoot is the result of rapid growth, a limit to that growth and finally the failure to recognise and stay within that limit - resulting in overshoot.

Not surprisingly the authors advocate sustainability as the solution to avoid overshoot. Sustainability, they state, is the next revolution. In the chapter on Tools for the Transition to Sustainability they spell out the structure for survival - visioning, networking, truth-telling, learning and loving.

Seems so simple, doesn't it.

Review: RA






The Solar Economy:
Renewable Energy for a Sustainable Global Future

by Hermann Scheer, Earthscan



Energy is now a political issue. It ceased to be an environmental problem many years ago.

Although slightly out of date (it was first published in German in 1999), Dr Scheer's book is the bible for those countries who want to plan a solar economy as part of their state policy and make solar energy available to communities. As a member of the German parliament, Dr Scheer's analysis is based on the pragmatic choices modern Germany (and neighbouring Switzerland) had to make to start introducing a solar economy. This is the blueprint.

Dr Scheer:

"The globalisation
process is a roller-coaster ride driven by fossil
fuels. The faster it goes, the more frightening
and bruising a ride it is for human passengers
and the natural world alike. Dwindling numbers of
people are able to climb aboard, while growing
proportions are tossed out of the carriage. By
contrast, the new division of labour in the solar
economy to come encompasses a whole variety of
swings and roundabouts, some small, some large,
all offering a much calmer ride, much less
violent to - and more under the control of -
their passengers. The solar global economy
affords much greater freedom and scope for the
productive use of technology because of the
countless individual practical applications that,
in combination with the immediate availability of
the sun's power, it makes possible."

Review: RA






Irish Trees:
Myths, Legends and Folklore

by Niall Mac Coitir (water-colours - Grania Langrishe), The Collins Press



Although this book was published in 2003 and followed with a paperback it is gradually going out of print.

It should be ubiquitous in every Irish home, a text for children, an entertainment for those who understand the importance of trees to the Irish psyche and a reminder that our modern lives are still informed by the language of the trees.

Mac Coitir asserts that this "is a book for all those frustrated by the [lack of mention that folklore gets in books about trees] and who want to know more about the sorely neglected (and dare I say important) topic of tree folklore".

It is at once much more than that. Supported by a grant from the Heritage Council, The Collins Press have produced a beautiful book with easy-to-identify pictures of leaves, berries, flowers and boughs, which are complimented by the excellent line drawings of Grania Langrishe. The chapters on the Ogham alphabet (a tree alphabet used by the Celts) and on the Ogham tree calendar alone are worth the price of the book.

Review: RA






Eat More Raw:
A Guide to Health and Sustainability

by Steve Charter, Permaculture Publications



This could have been a much better book if it had been aimed at the general population instead of the elite that concern themselves these days with the concept and practicality of permaculture.

It is a personal account of the journey Steve Charter has taken to reach the point in his life where raw food (the diet of the gatherer) is an integral aspect of his internal mind-body-spirit system.

"My main intellectual reasons for eating
as I do are guided by applying ecological
thinking, as well as permaculture ideas and other
ethical considerations and principles to my
choices of what and how I eat. This is
complemented by a healthy dose of well researched
information on diet, nutrition and lifestyle -
including looking at ... what creates sickness,
disease and ill-health, and what creates health."

What Charter wants to do is link raw food with permaculture and get people to apply to their lives the philosophies of eco-thinkers like Robert Hart (who pioneered woodland gardening) and Bill Mollison (who is regarded as the inventor of permaculture).

It fails because it is neither a cookbook nor a philosophy, yet it could have been both with a little more thought.

Review: RA






The Earth Care Manual:
A Permaculture Handbook for Britain and other Temperate Climates

by Patrick Whitefield, Permaculture Publications



Organic farmers, permaculturists, forest farmers and woodland gardeners of these islands (Ireland and Britain) have been waiting for this book for a long time.

Bill Mollison's books are fine if you live in southern Australia, John Seymour's The Self-Sufficient Gardener if you are rich and live in utopia, Rodale's How to Grow Vegetables and Fruits by the Organic Method if you trust what other growers are telling you about their specific land and climate and Nicolas Lampkin's Organic Farming if you are a commercial farmer wanting a technical manual for converting to organic.

Whitefield has produced a thick A4-sized book that complements his work as a permaculture teacher [though this too is around 40 quid - Ed]. And like the best teaching aids it seeks to involve the pupil at their own level.

"I'm not here to tell you what to do," Whitefield
proclaims. "My aim is to give you the wherewithal
to make your own decisions. This includes
information, but perhaps more importantly it
includes concepts and perspectives. The most
important thing to know in any situation is which
questions to ask. Then at least we have a chance
of coming up with the right answer. If we ask the
wrong question we have no chance."

There is little fear that any reader, once they have read The Earth Care Manual, will ask the wrong question. This is both a philosophical and practical guide to understanding why the production of food is more than mere need.

Permaculture, Whitefield insists, is "the direction we must go in if we're going to survive on this planet". It starts with the basics and principles of permaculture and moves through the pages to cover climate, water and energy, design and gardens, farms and food links, fruit, nuts and poultry, woodland and biodiversity. These cover the holistic complexity of permaculture, whether applied in the garden, small holding or farm.

The book will be a success if it reaches out to everyone and not just those who have already been converted.

Review: RA






The State of the World's Cities:
Globalization and Urban Culture

by United Nations Human Settlements Program, Earthscan

The State of the World Atlas:
A Unique Survey of Current Events and Global Trends

by Michael Kidron (Editor), Ronald Segal (Editor), Dan Smith (Editor), Earthscan

The State of the World
by Lester Brown et al, Earthscan



Any student armed with these books, the latter a series that began in 1984, will have sufficient statistical ammunition to counter all the arguments that everything is fine with the planet, its resources, climate and inhabitants.

Only the ignorant (usually industrialists and politicians) will argue that human society is not on a collision course with the inevitable, that atrophy and collapse are not around the corner, and that globalisation is not impacting negatively on our societies.

The State of the World's Cities, a glimpse into urban culture by the United Nations Habitat programme, emphasises the argument that globalisation is having a detrimental effect on our cities - which have become sinks for inequality, corruption, crime, violence and the societal problems that result from deteriorating living conditions and space, bad and poor diets, unsafe water, inadequate sanitation and low incomes.

As accessible and readable as this report is, it is still a UN report and therefore full of the rhetoric that needs to be funnelled into positive action rather than discussed in the ivory towers of the elites.

A more interesting and more direct book is Dan Smith's The State of the World Atlas.

It covers with an acute and perspicacious narrative supported by clear illustrations the elements that make up our societies - power, the cost of living, differences, rights, war and force, money, the business of pleasure, and life and death.

This is an at-a-glance book that informs both in picture and in word the state of the world today.

Whereas Worldwatch Institute's The State of World series is both idealistic and pragmatic. It celebrates the work of people around the world who are fighting for change while striving to highlight the problems facing the world. The latest volume concerns itself with the impact of war on our societies.

Sadly the Worldwatch Institute, a worthy albeit conservative organisation, is careful, subtitling the book 'Global Security' to ensure that the administration of Bush and Co is not offended.

It would be easy to offend Bush's administration because the impact of their nation's policies on the world are contained in the facts of this book. Food and water security matter more to the global population than the senseless and relentless exploitation of the earth's resources.

Still the Worldwatch Institute's insistence that the purpose of the book is to show what needs to be done to build lasting peace and security for all people is admirable.

Review: RA






Winning the Oil Endgame:
Innovation for Profits, Jobs and Security

by George P. Schulz (Foreword), Sir Mark Moody-Stuart (Foreword), Amory B. Lovins, Earthscan/Rocky Mountain Institute



http://www.oilendgame.com

First announced in September 2004,

http://www.ems.org/nws/2004/09/20/us_can_eliminate

when the American media hailed the Rocky Mountain Institute's report on how to end humanity's dependence on oil, the book is now available worldwide.

Despite the eulogies Lovins's carefully argued report has received from the audience it has been marketed at - neo-liberal capitalists and psuedo-liberal greens - those skeptical of techno-fixes are not convinced. While the biofuel industry is in full flow in Europe and many European countries are turning to hydro-electric, solar, wind and wave energy, it is the US that gobbles oil and refuses to take seriously these alternative energy sources.

Lovins acknowleges this: "Europe produces 17 times more biodiesel than we do," he says. "Unlike previous proposals to force oil savings through government policy, our proposed transition beyond oil is led by business for profit. Our recommendations are market-based, innovation-driven without mandates, and designed to support, not distort, business logic. They're self-financing and would cause the federal deficit to go down, not up."

An interesting report, but as one critic put it, if this is Plan B what is Plan Z?

Review: RA






Reviewers:

RA - Robert Allen
TB - Tim Barton
SB - Steve Booth
ED - Éanna Dowling
EV - Eric Valencic

This page is available for sponsorship






| Back | Index | The Dioxin War by Rob Allen |



BLUE is looking for short fiction, extracts of novels, poetry, lyrics, polemics, opinions, eyewitness accounts, reportage, features, information and arts in any form relating to eco cultural- social- spiritual issues, events and activites
(creative and political). Send to Newsdesk.